Hot Toddy Variations Apple Cider Hot Toddy: In this variation, we kick things up with the inclusion of apple cider, as well as some warming spices and aromatics, to really drive home the comfort. A hot toddy is a hot drink of liquor, water, honey, lemon, and spices, often used as a nightcap or a cold remedy. Learn about its origin, etymology, and different recipes, such as the cold toddy with oranges and ginger. Learn how to make a classic Hot Toddy with whiskey, hot water, sugar and lemon. This drink is a warming and comforting cocktail for cold nights or colds. Warm up with this classic hot toddy cocktail recipe! Hot toddies are so easy to make. You'll just need hot water, whiskey, honey, and lemon. Cheers!